The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutR16-041 Hearings on Taxpayer Generated Petitions for Abatement and Refund of Taxes Commissioner moved adoption of the following Resolution: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COUNTY OF EAGLE, STATE OF COLORADO Resolution No. 2016 - RESOLUTION CONCERNING HEARINGS ON TAXPAYER GENERATED PETITIONS FOR ABATEMENT AND REFUND OF TAXES BEFORE THE EAGLE COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners for Eagle County, Colorado (hereinafter referred to as the "Board") is responsible for hearing petitions for refund or abatement of property taxes pursuant to C.R.S. §§ 39-1-113 and 39-10-114; and WHEREAS, various petitions for abatement have been submitted to the Board by taxpayers for the purposes of correcting alleged erroneous valuations for assessment, irregularity in levying, clerical errors and/or overvaluations; and WHEREAS, said petitions have been previously submitted to the Eagle County Assessor (the "Assessor") for consideration and recommendation; and WHEREAS, the Board has appointed an independent hearing referee experienced in property valuation (the "Referee") to conduct hearings on behalf of the Board, to make findings based upon testimony and evidence presented by taxpayers and Assessor's representatives, and to submit recommendations to the Board for its final decision; and WHEREAS, the Referee has submitted his recommendations to the Board for its final decision, the Board has considered such recommendations and such recommendations are attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and incorporated herein by this reference. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of County Commissioners of Eagle County, Colorado: THAT, the Board hereby approves the recommendations of the Referee for the schedule numbers, the tax years and for the reasons set forth in the Referee's recommendation sheets attached hereto as Exhibit "A" and enters orders with respect to the petitions for abatement in accordance with such recommendations. THAT, for each order issued by the Board in which an adjustment to the respective Petitioners' valuation is indicated, subject to approval by the State Property Tax Administrator where required by the terms of C.R.S. § 39-1-113(3), the Board directs the Assessor to adjust the valuation or take such other action as more particularly set forth in the recommendations set forth and attached hereto as Exhibit"A." 4. .,► • FORM orAli t ag'e Cou tto - s Office -- Ea ,e Ccur. •C3ir;rn;;stoners' Office BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that a petition denied, in whole or in part, by the Board can be appealed to the Board of Assessment Appeals within thirty (30) days pursuant to C.R.S. 39-2-125. The appeal forms and instructions for appeal to the Board of Assessment Appeals may be obtained from the Board of Assessment Appeals, Department of Local Affairs, 1313 Sherman Street, Room 315, Denver, Colorado 80203. MOVED, READ AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of the County of Eagle, State of Colorado at its regular meeting held the 11 day of IM.44 , 2016. ,di"Atte COUNTY OF EAGLE, STATE OF It COLORADO, By and Through Its 1,„ e BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ATTEST: • �V.1�L �I c�t k nac.�it a �i By. •I _ Clerk to tli� Board of It-..nne Queen- County Commissio .it �-� 041V1`• Al�� ha . Ryan �C sp ;•sione, Kat y Ch .ler-Henry Commissioner Commissioner 441 _.- t4t.,4- -seconded adoption of the foregoing resolution. The roll having been called, the vote was as follows: Commissioner McQueeney Commissioner Ryan ,,. Commissioner Chandler-Henry k This resolution passed by / vote of the Board of County Commissioners of the County of Eagle, State of Colorado 2 March 29, 2016 R059967 Parcel #2467-074-63-004 Owner: COLORADO LA PALOMA INC/Travis Stuard -Agent Assessor's Original Value $351,110 (2015) Petitioner's Value $351,110 (2015) Referee's Recommendation: $351,110 (2015) Classification: Vacant Land Abatement Tax Year(s):2015 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on March 29, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Travis Stuard. Respondent was represented by Patrick Corcoran and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. 05 12!2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R008000 Parcel#2101-081-05-001 Owner: LIBRA HOLDINGS LLC/Roger Pack-Agent Assessor's Original Value $1,818,140 (2013 &2014) Petitioner's Value $1,665,000 (2013 &2014) Referee's Recommendation: $1,818,140 (2013 &2014) Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Bonnie Embry and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. 21/ 9 04/21/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R042693 Parcel#2101-082-68-001 Owner: CHARLES A. MCMUNN REVOCABLE TRUST/Roger Pack -Agent Assessor's Original Value $6,071,040 (2013 &2014) Petitioner's Value $5,600,000 (2013 &2014) Referee's Recommendation: $6,071,040 (2013 &2014) Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Bonnie Embry and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. 04/2=1/21 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R048918 Parcel#2105-142-01-069 Owner: DRG RESORTS LLC, FRANK AND MARCIA DEL RIO/Roger Pack-Agent Assessor's Original Value $4,319,540 (2013&2014) Assessed Value: $343,833 Petitioner's Value $3,920,000 (2013 &2014) Asssessed Value: $312,030 Referee's Recommendation: $4,120,000 (2013 &2014) Assessed Value: $327,950 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Kristina Birk and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend an adjustment. 04/21/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R040190 Parcel # 1943-361-07-017 Owner: GUSTAFSON, JAMES E. &JEANNE/Roger Pack-Agent Assessor's Original Value $4,193,830 (2013 &2014) Assessed Value: $333,828 Petitioner's Value $3,950,000 (2013 &2014) Assessed Value: $314,419 Referee's Recommendation: $3,965,080 (2013 &2014) Assessed Value: $315,620 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Kristina Birk and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend an adjustment. / sue- 04/21/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R011682 Parcel # 2105-133-01-014 Owner: JOANN G. HICKEY QUALIFIED PERSONAL RESIDENCE TRUST I, LEON GONZALEZ TRUSTEE - ETAL/Roger Pack -Agent Assessor's Original Value $2,848,250 (2013&2014) Petitioner's Value $2,425,000 (2013 &2014) Referee's Recommendation: $2,848,250 (2013 &2014) Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Kristina Birk and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. jr." /0 04/21/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R040211 Parcel# 1943-361-08-007 Owner: COYER, AMY J. &STEVEN C./Roger Pack -Agent Assessor's Original Value $4,110,720 (2013 &2014) Petitioner's Value $3,350,000 (2013 &2014) Referee's Recommendation: $4,110,720 (2013 &2014) Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Kristina Birk and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. 04/21/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R040177 Parcel # 1943-361-07-004 Owner: SCHULTZ, DEBORAH Z. &JAMES H. / Roger Pack -Agent Assessor's Original Value $4,131,030 (2013 &2014) Petitioner's Value $3,500,000 (2013 &2014) Referee's Recommendation: $4,131,030 (2013 &2014) Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Kristina Birk and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. -may} ��^ 04/21/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R045300 Parcel#2105-144-01-014 Owner: SANKEY, JAMES & BETH /Roger Pack-Agent Assessor's Original Value $4,500,000 (2013 &2014) Petitioner's Value $3,175,000 (2013 &2014) Referee's Recommendation: $4,500,000 (2013 &2014) Classification: Vacant Land Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Kristina Birk and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. .00-e /4/ 04/25/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R048561 Parcel #2105-142-01-061 Owner: SANKEY, JAMES & BETH /Roger Pack -Agent Assessor's Original Value $4,128,070 (2013 &2014) Assessed Value: $328,591 Petitioner's Value $3,625,000 (2013 &2014) Assessed Value: $288,547 Referee's Recommendation: $3,638,730 (2013 &2014) Assessed Value: $289,640 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Kristina Birk and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend an adjustment. 04/25/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R009558 Parcel #2101-081-01-004 Owner: SUSAN REPETTI RUTHERFORD MANAGEMENT TRUS /Roger Pack -Agent Assessor's Original Value $1,277,200 (2013 &2014) Petitioner's Value $1,050,000 (2013 &2014) Referee's Recommendation: $1,277,200 (2013 &2014) Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Andie Noakes and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. 04/25/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R012420 Parcel#2101-122-13-001 Owner: CARNIE LIVING TRUST / Roger Pack -Agent Assessor's Original Value $1,067,020 (2013 &2014) Petitioner's Value $820,000 (2013 &2014) Referee's Recommendation: $1,067,020 (2013 &2014) Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Andie Noakes and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. 04/25/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R039444 Parcel#2101-123-13-009 Owner: LAW, SUSAN C. /Roger Pack -Agent Assessor's Original Value $1,633,350 (2013 &2014) Assessed Value: $ 130,010 Petitioner's Value $1,280,000 (2013 &2014) Assessed Value: $ 101,884 Referee's Recommendation: $1,433,210 (2013 &2014) Assessed Value: $ 114,080 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2013 &2014 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s) were represented by Roger Pack. Respondent was represented by Andie Noakes and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend an adjustment. / 4/ /7;,/,0, 04/26/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 25, 2016 R054454 Parcel#2107-014-01-033 Owner: BEHRINGER HARVARD CORDILLERA LLC /Joe Monzon -Agent Assessor's Original Value $12,122,250 (2015) Petitioner's Value $10,000,000 (2015) Referee's Recommendation: $12,122,250 (2015) Classification: Residential •Abatement Tax Year(s) 2015 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven via teleconference on April 25, 2016, Petitioner(s) were represented by Joe Monzon. Respondent was represented by Ryan Kane and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. PFD ,: % 04/27/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A April 18, 2016 R040266 Parcel# 1943-364-09-011 Owner: DONAHUGH, JAMES P. & DEBRA L./Travis Stuard -Agent Assessor's Original Value $1,155,000 (2014); $990,000 (2015) Petitioner's Value $1,155,000 (2014); $990,000 (2015) Referee's Recommendation: $1,155,000 (2014); $990,000 (2015) Classification:Vacant Land • Abatement Tax Year(s):2014 &2015 Reason: THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem van der Hoeven on April 18, 2016. Petitioner(s)were represented by Travis Stuard. Respondent was represented by Kristina Birk and Kevin Cassidy. I recommend denial. Ve1/62 04/21/2016 Willem van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date EXHIBIT A