No preview available
HomeMy WebLinkAboutR20-044 Hearings on Taxpayer Generated Petitions for Abatement and Refund of Taxes DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861 DCC-851 B-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Scherr Commissioner moved adoption of the following Resolution: BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS COUNTY OF EAGLE, STATE OF COLORADO Resolution No. 2020 - 044 RESOLUTION CONCERNING HEARINGS ON TAXPAYER GENERATED PETITIONS FOR ABATEMENT AND REFUND OF TAXES BEFORE THE EAGLE COUNTY BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS WHEREAS, the Board of County Commissioners for Eagle County, Colorado (hereinafter referred to as the "Board") is responsible for hearing petitions for refund or abatement of property taxes pursuant to C.R.S. §§ 39-1-113 and 39-10-114; and WHEREAS, various petitions for abatement have been submitted to the Board by taxpayers for the purposes of correcting alleged erroneous valuations for assessment, irregularity in levying, clerical errors and/or overvaluations; and WHEREAS, said petitions have been previously submitted to the Eagle County Assessor (the "Assessor") for consideration and recommendation; and WHEREAS, the Board has appointed an independent hearing referee experienced in property valuation (the "Referee") to conduct a hearing on behalf of the Board, to make findings based upon testimony and evidence presented by taxpayers and Assessor's representatives, and to submit recommendations to the Board for its final decision; and WHEREAS, the Referee has submitted his recommendations to the Board for its final decision, the Board has considered such recommendations and such recommendations are attached hereto as Exhibit"A"and incorporated herein by this reference. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Board of County Commissioners of Eagle County, Colorado: THAT, the Board hereby approves the recommendations of the Referee for the schedule numbers, the tax year(s) and for the reasons set forth in the Referee's recommendations sheets attached hereto as Exhibit "A," and enters an order with respect to each petition for abatement in accordance with such recommendations. THAT, for each order issued by the Board in which an adjustment to the respective Petitioners' valuation is indicated, subject to approval by the State Property Tax Administrator where required by the terms of C.R.S. § 39-1-113(3), the Board directs the Assessor to adjust the valuation or take such other action as more particularly set forth in the recommendations set forth and attached hereto as Exhibit"A." DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861DCC-851B-4DF0-BAF3-500CA238B370 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED,that a petition denied, in whole or in part, by the Board can be appealed to the Board of Assessment Appeals within thirty(30) days pursuant to C.R.S. 39-2-125. The appeal forms and instructions for appeal to the Board of Assessment Appeals may be obtained from the Board of Assessment Appeals, Department of Local Affairs, 1313 Sherman Street, Room 315, Denver, Colorado 80203. MOVED, READ AND ADOPTED by the Board of County Commissioners of the County of Eagle, State of Colorado at its - meeting held the23rd day of June , 2020. EAGie s COUNTY OF EAGLE, STATE OF COLORADO, By and Through Its BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS ATTEST:1—D'usign"b' cbt OR AO° __DocuSignedby: uu 61-lbritAk. By: 6461 ( r—kt-lAtti Clerk to th' Mdl51 ° Kat ty-eliftlitikfftnenry County Commissioners Chir DocuSigned by: htlif Sat/yr lvi atlEtE0473 Commissioner Jeanne McQueeney Commissioner Chandler-Henry Commissioner seconded adoption of the foregoing resolution. The roll having been called, the vote was as follows: Comm issioner Chandler-I lenry Aye Commissioner Schur Aye Commissioner McQueeney Absent This resolution passed by 2/0 vote of the Board of County Commissioners of the County of Eagle, State of Colorado 2 DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861DCC-851B-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 R039425 Parcel#2105-123-13-013 Owner: Robert Douglas Bruinsma Basis of appeal(please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $2,410,620 7.20 % $ 173,560 Petitioner's Estimate $2,210,000 7.20 % $ 159,120 Referee's Recommendation $2,410,620 7.20 % $ 173,560 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Kristina Birk THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, ❑ Partial Approval, ❑Approval _ rid �% ` ° 5/13/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date ovcvsignEnvelope ID:azuo1oco-8n, Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 R028816 Parcel#2105-244-01-010 Owner: 90 Elk Tract Ct, LLC Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation D Classification Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $4.444.628 7.20 % $ 320,010 Petitioner's Estimate $3,350,000 7.20% $241,200 Referee's Recommendation $4,062,340 7.2096 $292,490 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Kristina Birk THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L.van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: Lii Denial, X Partial Approval, El Approval 5/13/2020 Willem L. van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861DCC-8518-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 • R040880 Parcel#2107-104-01-005 Owner: Fisher, Donne F. Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $225,000 29.0 % $65,250 Petitioner's Estimate $ 130,000 29.0% $ 37,700 Referee's Recommendation $ 185,750 29.0 % $ 53,870 Classification: Vacant Land Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Melody Woolsey THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: ❑ Denial, X Partial Approval, ❑ Approval Fl ! jr �. 5/14/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861 DCC-851 B-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 R044060 Parcel#2107-141-05-003 Owner: Schneiderman, Leonard A. &Jean A. Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $2,896,160 7.20% $208,520 Petitioner's Estimate $2,470,000 7.20 % $ 177,840 Referee's Recommendation $2,896,160 7.20 % $208,520 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Melody Woolsey THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, ❑ Partial Approval, ❑Approval r1f it 5/14/2020 Willem L. van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861 DCC-851 B-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 R049623 Parcel#2107-153-01-001 Owner: Moran, Dennis&Cindy Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation E Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $ 3,148,420 7.20% $226,680 Petitioner's Estimate $2,850,000 7.20% $205,200 Referee's Recommendation $ 3,148,420 7.20% $226,680 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Melody Woolsey THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, ❑ Partial Approval, ❑ Approval • 5/14/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861DCC-851B-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 R049652 Parcel#2107-164-03-003 Owner: Anderson, Carlene-Peterson, David Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $2,519,440 7.20% $ 181,400 ' Petitioner's Estimate $2,250,000 7.20 % $162,000 Referee's Recommendation $2,519,440 7.20 % $ 181,400 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Melody Woolsey THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, ❑ Partial Approval, ❑ Approval r-) P 5/14/2020 Willem L. van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861 DCC-851 B-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 R049841 Parcel#2107-154-01-009 Owner: Zinna Family Trust Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $ 3,925,630 7.20% $282,640 Petitioner's Estimate $3,700,000 7.20 % $266,400 Referee's Recommendation $ 3,925,630 7.20 % $282,640 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Melody Woolsey THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, ❑ Partial Approval, ❑ Approval - amu' ... 5/14/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A285ooC*m m Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 R050901 Parcel#2107'1G4'OG'OO1 Owner: Pelz, David T. &Joann Basis of appeal (please check one): X Valuation 0 Classification 0 Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $275,600 29.0% $79,920 Petitioner's Estimate $ 100,000 29.0% $28.0O0 Referee's Recommendation $275,600 29.O96 $79,920 Classification: Vacant Land Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017 &2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Melody Woolsey THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L.van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, 0 Partial Approval, [] Approval 5/14/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date omomunEnvelope ID:azoo1occ-8me4npo-BApx-5nonAonnyx/o Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 RO52O17 Parcel#2105'152'O1'O13 Owner: Cresta Property Holdings LLC Basis of appeal(please check one):X Valuation El Classification El Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $ 9,299,250 7.20 % $669,550 Petitioner's Estimate $7,850,000 7.20% $ 565,200 Referee's Recommendation $ 9,299,250 7.20% $669,550 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Kristina Birk THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L.van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, El Partial Approval, E Approval 5/13/2020 Willem VWUamLvonderHoexen. Hemhng0ffims Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861 DCC-851 B-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 R052117 Parcel# 1941-213-01-006 Owner: Lot 81 Red Sky LLC Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $445,000 29.0% $ 129,050 Petitioner's Estimate $ 350,000 29.0% $ 101,500 Referee's Recommendation $ 350,000 29.0 % $101,500 Classification: Vacant Land Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Melody Woolsey THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: ❑ Denial, ❑ Partial Approval,X Approval 5/14/2020 Willem L. van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date oon munsnvownvuzmmo ooc-851 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/5/2020 RO52127 Parcel# 1941-213-02-007 Owner: Ferguson, Kristin V. Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation El Classification El Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $3,436,720 7.20% $247,450 Petitioner's Estimate $ 3,000,000 72096 $216,000 Referee's Recommendation $ 3,167,410 7.20 % $228,050 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Melody Woolsey THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 5, 2020. Recommendation: O Denial, X Partial Approval, LI Approval /2. /.!,�,'^��' 5/14/2O2O Willem L. van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861DCC-8518-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/6/2020 R060797 Parcel#2101-082-84-002 Owner: One Willow Bridge Road Association Inc. Basis of appeal(please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $4,378,330 7.20 % ' $ 315,240 Petitioner's Estimate $ 3,990,000 7.20 % $287,280 Referee's Recommendation $4,283,810 7.20% $ 308,430 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L.van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: ❑ Denial, X Partial Approval, ❑ Approval rt /' „- 5/15/2020 Willem L. van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date oouvsionEnvelope ID:*uon1ooC-uu113-4oro-BApx-5no:puouuxm Abatement Hearing Date: 5/6/2020 R060798 Parcel#2101-082-84-003 Owner: One Willow Bridge Road Association Inc. Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation EJ Classification D Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $ 3,508,480 7.20 % $252,610 Petitioner's Estimate $ 3,180,000 7.20 % $228,960 Referee's Recommendation $ 3,508,480 7.20 % $252,610 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: X Denia|, O Partial Approval, G Approval ' - /���_ ' 5/15/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date onooigoEnvelope ID:^2no1ouo-8o1 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/6/2020 R060799 Parcel#2101'UB2-84-0O4 Owner: One Willow Bridge Road Association Inc. Basis of appeal(please check one):X Valuation Classification Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $4.508.1BO 7.20 % $ 324.590 Petitioner's Estimate $4,250,000 7.2O96 $ 306,000 Referee's Recommendation $4.5O8.1DO 7.20% $ 324,590 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer VVillem L. van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, LI Partial Approval, []Approval / ,/ / � � — / ' /~ ~ = 5/15/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861DCC-851B-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/6/2020 R060800 Parcel#2101-082-84-005 Owner: One Willow Bridge Road Association Inc. Basis of appeal(please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $4,644,650 7.20% $334,410 Petitioner's Estimate $4,370,000 7.20% $ 314,640 Referee's Recommendation $4,644,650 7.20% $ 334,410 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, ❑ Partial Approval, ❑Approval oo: oignsnvmvneuD:A28*1oco-85 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/6/2020 R060801 Parcel#21O1'U82'84'OOS Owner: One Willow Bridge Road Association Inc. Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation D Classification Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $5,103,230 7.20% $367.430 Petitioner's Estimate $4,370,000 7.20% $314,640 Referee's Recommendation $4,988,400 7.20 % $359,160 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: [] Denial, X Partial Approval, O Approval /, /�, ~ '/ . �—� ^'�� /,' 5/15/2020 V0|em L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date ovc sNnsnvewpwxzAzoo ooC-85 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/0/2020 R060802 Parcel#2101'0B2-84'OO7 Owner: One Willow Bridge Road Association Inc. Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation El Classification El Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $ 5,243,630 7.20% $377,540 Petitioner's Estimate $4,895,000 7.20% $ 352,440 Referee's Recommendation $5,056,380 7.20 % $ 364,060 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: [] Denial, X Partial Approval, [] Approval / /l / {/ , 7 / ' *p �� ( �' - , ' °~ 'r'' 5/15/202O Willem L. van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861DCC-851B-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/6/2020 R060806 Parcel#2101-082-84-011 Owner: One Willow Bridge Road Association Inc. Basis of appeal(please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification 0 Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $3,805,690 7.20 % $274,010 Petitioner's Estimate $ 3,270,000 7.20 % $235,440 Referee's Recommendation $3,618,920 7.20% $260,560 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: 0 Denial,X Partial Approval, 0 Approval 5/15/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861DCC-8518-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/6/2020 R060807 Parcel#2101-082-84-012 Owner: One Willow Bridge Road Association Inc. Basis of appeal(please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification D Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $4,890,440 7.20% $ 352,110 Petitioner's Estimate $4,375,000 7.20 % $ 315,000 Referee's Recommendation $4,751,720 7.20% $ 341,120 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: ❑ Denial, X Partial Approval, ❑ Approval / 5/15/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date ovousionEnvelope ID:*umo1ocC-8mm+opo'eAFx'000cazuouom Abatement Hearing Date: 586/2020 R060808 Parcel#21U1'U82'84'O13 Owner: One Willow Bridge Road Association Inc. Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation D Classification Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $4,732,390 7.20 % $ 340,730 Petitioner's Estimate $4,250,000 7.2096 • $ 306.000 Referee's Recommendation $4,732,390 7.20% $ 340,730 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, O Partial Approval, O Approval . - ,�"-^��- 5/15/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861DCC-8518-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/6/2020 R060810 Parcel#2101-082-84-015 Owner: One Willow Bridge Road Association Inc. Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $4,957,040 7.20 % $356,910 Petitioner's Estimate $4,445,000 7.20% $ 320,040 Referee's Recommendation $4,803,600 7.20% $ 345,860 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: ❑ Denial,X Partial Approval, ❑ Approval -.-� 5/15/2020 Willem L.van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861 DCC-851 B-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 5/6/2020 R060811 Parcel#2101-082-84-016 Owner: Joshua Rose LLC Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $4,605,890 7.20% $331,620 Petitioner's Estimate $4,445,000 7.20 % $ 320,040 Referee's Recommendation $4,605,890 7.20 % $ 331,620 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Bonnie Embry THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on May 6, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, ❑ Partial Approval, ❑Approval • // f`f r Y ,-,;/rY ,r sw _ 5/15/2020 Willem L. van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date DocuSign Envelope ID:A2861DCC-8518-4DFO-BAF3-500CA238B370 Abatement Hearing Date: 6/3/2020 R08761 Parcel#2103-122-05-002 Owner: Madden, John W. III Basis of appeal (please check one):X Valuation ❑ Classification ❑ Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $ 1,140,000 29.00% $330,600 Petitioner's Estimate $ 855,000 29.00% $247,950 Referee's Recommendation $ 1,140,000 29.00% $ 330,600 Classification: Vacant Residential Land Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017&2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Andrea Noakes THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer Willem L. van der Hoeven on June 3, 2020. Recommendation: X Denial, ❑ Partial Approval, E Approval may' 6/5/2020 Willem L. van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date ovwmnnEnvelope ID:*zou1oCc-8s B-4opo-B»p3-500cx238u3/0 Abatement Hearing Date: 6/3/2020 R009858 Parcel#2101-092-03-005 Owner: Tiner, Michael L. &Beth B. Basis of appeal (please check one): X Valuation [] Classification O Other—describe Original Value Assessment Rate Assessed Value Assessor's $ 5,417,960 7.2096 $ 390,090 PatiUnner'oEudmata $4,850,000 7.20% $349,200 Referee's Recommendation $ 5,144,360 7.20% $ 370,394 Classification: Residential Abatement Tax Year(s) 2017 &2018 The Petitioner was represented by: Roger Pack,Agent The Assessor was represented by: Andrea Noakes THIS MATTER was heard by Hearing Officer VVillem L. van der Hoeven on June 3, 2020. Recommendation: O Denial, X Partial Approval, [] Approval // �/�/ ��''��^��_ �"C'1~- G/5/2O20 Willem L. van der Hoeven, Hearing Officer Date